Moment.js vs. Day.js: Which One Should You Use?

Photo by Praveen Thirumurugan on Unsplash

Working with dates and times in JavaScript can be a headache. Thankfully, libraries like Moment.js and Day.js have come to the rescue, making date manipulation more straightforward. But with both options available, which one should you choose for your next project? Let’s dive into an easy-to-understand comparison to help you decide.

Understanding the Basics

Before we delve into the comparison, let’s briefly understand what these libraries are.

• Moment.js: Released in 2011, Moment.js quickly became the go-to library for date and time manipulation in JavaScript. It offers a comprehensive set of features to parse, validate, manipulate, and display dates and times.
• Day.js: Introduced in 2018, Day.js emerged as a modern alternative to Moment.js. Its primary selling point is its lightweight nature, aiming to provide similar functionality with a much smaller footprint.

Importance of Library Size

When selecting a JavaScript library, the size of the library can significantly impact your application’s performance, especially in terms of load time and responsiveness.

• Moment.js: With all its built-in features, Moment.js comes in at around 300KB uncompressed (roughly 67KB when minified and gzipped). While this isn’t enormous, it can add noticeable weight to your application, especially if you’re building a web app that needs to load quickly on various devices and network conditions.
• Day.js: In contrast, Day.js is designed to be extremely lightweight. At just 2KB (minified and gzipped), it’s nearly imperceptible in terms of loading time. This makes Day.js an appealing choice for developers focused on performance optimization, particularly in resource-constrained environments.

Verdict: If your goal is to build a fast, lean application, Day.js offers a significant advantage in terms of size. This smaller footprint can lead to faster load times, better performance on mobile devices, and an overall smoother user experience.

Feature Set and Plugins

Both libraries offer a range of features, but there are differences in how they approach extensibility.

• Moment.js: Comes packed with a vast array of functionalities out of the box. From time zones to localization, many features are readily available. Additionally, Moment.js has a rich ecosystem of plugins to extend its capabilities further.
• Day.js: Adopts a modular approach. The core library is minimal, and additional features are available as plugins. This design ensures you only include what you need, keeping the size minimal.

Verdict: If you need comprehensive features without the hassle of managing plugins, Moment.js is more straightforward. However, if you prefer a lean setup and are comfortable adding plugins as needed, Day.js offers flexibility.

Performance

Beyond size, performance in terms of execution speed is crucial.

• Moment.js: Given its size and the breadth of its features, Moment.js can be slower, especially when handling large datasets or performing complex date manipulations.
• Day.js: Designed to be fast. Its minimalist design ensures quicker execution times, making it suitable for performance-critical applications.

Day.js generally offers better performance due to its lightweight nature.

Mutability

How these libraries handle data mutations is another point of difference.

• Moment.js: Mutable by default. This means that operations on a Moment.js object can change its original value, which might lead to unexpected behaviors if not handled carefully.
• Day.js: Immutable. Every operation returns a new Day.js object, leaving the original untouched. This approach reduces potential bugs related to unintended data mutations.

Day.js’s immutability aligns with modern programming best practices, making it a safer choice in this regard.

Time Zone Support

Handling time zones is often a critical requirement in applications.

• Moment.js: Offers robust time zone support through the Moment Timezone plugin. It’s comprehensive and widely used.
• Day.js: Provides time zone capabilities via the TimeZone plugin. While functional, it might not be as extensive as Moment’s offering.

Verdict: If your project needs to handle time zones in a detailed and complex way, Moment.js might be the better choice.

Localization

Displaying dates and times in various formats based on locale is common.

• Moment.js: Supports localization extensively, covering numerous languages and regional formats.
• Day.js: Also offers localization support through plugins. While it’s comprehensive, some developers find Moment’s localization slightly more mature.

Verdict: Both libraries handle localization well, but Moment.js has a slight edge due to its long-standing presence.

Community and Maintenance

The health and activity of a library’s community can influence its longevity and reliability.

• Moment.js: Being around for over a decade, it boasts a vast community. However, it’s worth noting that the Moment.js team announced in 2020 that they consider the project a legacy and recommend alternatives for new projects.
• Day.js: While newer, it has rapidly gained popularity. Its active development and growing community make it a strong contender.

Verdict: Given Moment.js’s legacy status, Day.js represents the future, with active maintenance and community support.

Learning Curve

For developers, especially those new to JavaScript, the ease of learning a library is crucial.

• Moment.js: Its comprehensive documentation and widespread use mean plenty of tutorials, examples, and community support are available.
• Day.js: Designed to be a straightforward drop-in replacement for Moment.js. Its API is almost identical, making the transition smooth. However, given its newer status, there might be slightly fewer resources available.

Both libraries are easy to learn, especially if you already know one of them. Since their APIs are similar, switching between them or learning either one is simple.

Real-world Usage

Understanding how these libraries fare in actual projects can provide insights.

• Moment.js: It has been the main choice for many years. Many existing projects still use it, and it has proven to be reliable.
• Day.js: Being newer, it’s rapidly adopted in modern projects, especially those prioritizing performance and minimalism.

For new projects, Day.js offers modern advantages. However, for maintaining or extending older projects, Moment.js might still be prevalent.

Conclusion: Which One Should You Choose?

The choice between Moment.js and Day.js boils down to your project’s specific needs.

• Choose Moment.js if:
• You require comprehensive features out of the box.
• Your project heavily relies on intricate time zone manipulations.
• You’re maintaining or extending an existing project that already uses Moment.js.
• Choose Day.js if:
• Performance and minimalism are priorities.
• You prefer immutable data structures to prevent unintended mutations.
• You’re starting a new project and want a modern, lightweight solution.
• You’re comfortable managing plugins to extend functionality as needed.

In the evolving landscape of JavaScript libraries, Day.js represents a shift towards leaner, more efficient tools. While Moment.js has served the developer community well for years, its legacy status suggests looking towards alternatives for new projects.

Ultimately, both libraries are powerful in their own right. Assess your project’s requirements, weigh the pros and cons, and make an informed choice.